| Rationale for the Award | ||||
TO
DO!2001
Award Winner
THE TOURISM PROJECT represented by Dr. Mathew and Leelamony Moozhiyil, Sreekandamangalam,
Township of Athirampuzha, Rationale
for the Award
"The poetry of travel lies in the organic absorption of newly acquired
knowledge, in the increase of our understanding of the unity in diversity,
and in rediscovering old truths and laws under completely new circumstances"
1. INTRODUCTION The expert appraiser visited the State of Kerala in Southern India from 14th-19th November 2001 on assignment from Studienkreis für Tourismus und Entwicklung e.V. (Institute for Tourism and Development). The object of his visit was to evaluate the BASIS INTERNATIONAL project with a registered office in Sreekandamangalam ("The City of Shiva"). The small village belongs to the township of Athirampuzha (pronounced Athirampura) and is located in the Kottayam district. The Project was entered into the TO DO!2001 contest by its German co-operation partner Waschbär-Reisen GmbH, Ballrechten. Thanks to the excellent
support provided by the BASIS staff and especially by BASIS co-founders,
Leelamony and Mathew Moozhiyil (pronounced Murhiyil) the assignment could
be completed without any complications. The expert appraiser gained comprehensive
insights into the working methods and organisational structure of BASIS.
The most important observations of the expert appraiser were discussed
with the Moozhiyil family before the return trip. 2. BACKGROUND With 33 million inhabitants, Kerala is the most densely populated state in India after West Bengal. Since the largest portion of the mainly rural population (app. 22 million) lives in scattered villages, "underneath trees" in the midst of the farmland, one does not get the impression of crowded conditions and overpopulation. The aerial view shows expansive forests interspersed with patches of cleared land. The "wilderness" is comprised mainly of palms and rubber trees (Kerala means "the country of palms"), amongst which the villages are located. The "land clearings" are really tea plantations and rice fields. Geographically, Kerala is divided into three regions: the coastal region (with a network of intertwined creeks and lagoons extending far into the interior, or so-called "backwaters"), the central uplands and the highlands (the so-called "Western Ghats", with mountains that reach up to 2,700 meters above sea level). Kerala has a rich variety of flora and fauna, which however is impaired by monocultures: in the lower areas by India rubber, in the higher planes by tea, coffee and cardamom plantations (rubber growers are subsidised by the government, and plantations are excluded from the land reform). About 25 percent of India's 15,000 plant varieties growing on arable land or grassland and, in the tropical rain forest and cloud forest are in this region. Two thirds of Kerala's 3,750 plant varieties are endemic to the region. This rich plant habitat provides a home to an exceptionally diverse animal kingdom: About 100 varieties of mammals, 550 varieties of birds and 170 types of reptiles cohabitate in this region, including antelopes, gazelles, tigers, leopards, buffalo, wild boar, wild dogs, elephants, various kinds of monkeys, bears, crocodiles, turtles and snakes. The animals live in and outside the 13 national parks and animal preserves, but are nevertheless exposed to hazards through monoculture, dams, deforestation, erosion, river silting, poaching, overfishing, industrial waste and pesticides. Kerala´s coastal region combines foreign influences with a variety of religious denominations. About 20 percent of the population is Christian, another 20 percent Muslim, and nearly 60 percent Hindus (compared to 2, 10, and 88 percent for all of India). Moreover, there is also a small group of Jews. In the home community of BASIS INTERNATIONAL, in Sreekandamangalam or Athirampuzha, however, the Christian population predominates. Churches, mosques, temples and synagogues are living testimony to the diversity of religious life in the region. No significant religious conflicts are known to exist. However, the fact that the Christian churches and Muslims are receiving increasing financial support from abroad, whilst Hindus are left to their own resources, and the fact that some Christian communities celebrate their main religious holidays with great pomp, noisily drowning the Hindus with loudspeakers, could possibly jeopardise this peaceful coexistence one day. The caste system in Kerala is very pronounced. The caste etiquette - particularly for interaction among the castes - is generally observed very strictly. Even Christians are divided into two castes: It was declared that the descendants of Hindus who had converted to Christianity up to the onset of British colonial rule belong to the (Christian) Brahmin caste and that Christians converting during British colonial rule and their descendants are lower caste, since many Hindus who let themselves be baptised during that period were from the lower castes. The Hindu Brahmins practised a patrilineal inheritance system, whilst the hierarchy of the lower castes was matrilineal - something which, however, does not preclude the general practice of patriarchal decision making. The work of Mahatma Gandhi and his disciples - in Kerala and particularly in Sree Narayana Guru - have rendered the caste system somewhat less rigid; however, certainly not sufficiently enough, as attested to by the fiery accusations made by Arundhati Roy, an author from the Kottayam District, in her book "The god of small things". Kerala has the highest literacy rate in all of India. It ranges between 90 and 100 percent depending on the age group. At the same time, this state has the largest percentage of unemployed persons with high professional qualifications. This is attributable to the fact that Kerala's industrialisation is not very advanced, and the dominant sectors are export-oriented industries such as agriculture, forestry, plantation farming and fisheries (with products such as India rubber, coconut products, tapioca, lemon grass oil, tea, coffee, spices, and cardamom). The subsistence mixed-culture economy has so strongly declined that it is forced to import meat, vegetables and grains. Kerala has a below-average per capita income and is one of the poorest states of India. Ironically, this state of things is also due to the halfway successful land reform and high educational levels: Machinery cannot be economically used on the small plots of land held by many owners, and the high level of education has led to the cultural devaluation of vocational and farming work, which has come to be viewed as inferior, in preference of the more desirable and prestigious "white collar jobs". The related risk of remaining unemployed over long periods is frequently accepted. Furthermore, the government quotas for university admissions of students from all castes into programmes which would prepare them for civil service, have encouraged many members of the lower castes to venture into the public service track, and this, in turn, only further aggravates the shortage of craftsmen.
Kerala has great ecological and socio-cultural tourism potential that is neither fully explored nor fully utilised. Therefore, Kerala's Department of Tourism recently approved the development of master plans for the coastal, backwater, and mountain regions (Western Ghats). 3. THE TOURISM PROJECT BASIS INTERNATIONAL AS PART OF THE BASIS PROJECT VILLAGE DEVELOPMENT 3.1 HISTORICAL BACKGROUND BASIS INTERNATIONAL is a part of BASIS Projects. BASIS is the abbreviation for "Basic Agricultural and Social Improvement Schemes". BASIS Projects was founded in May 1990 by Dr. Mathew Moozhiyil and his wife Mrs. Leelamony Moozhiyil in Sreekandamangalam. Both had previously lived and worked in Germany for 20 years; he as an agricultural scientist and she as a medical nurse. After their return to Kerala the couple purchased a two-hectare plot of land with house in Sreekandamangalam, which had belonged to a former rubber plantation owner, in part with private funding from Germany. The Moozhiyils replaced the damaging monoculture with adapted mixed crops (coconuts, papaya, mango, jackfruit, bananas, pineapple, cinnamon, nutmeg, spice clove, pepper, tuber fruits, rice). This approach has led to successful self-sustenance of about 20 persons per year. Any surplus produce is sold and provides the basic funds for subsequent project initiatives. The mixed crops on the compound of the Moozhiyil family are supplemented by livestock (cows, pigs, goats, chickens), whose waste is used as fertiliser, thus creating a balanced biological cycle. Moreover, the building of guest accommodations, kitchen and dining area next to the residence of the Moozhiyil family was financed from their own savings. Meanwhile, this infrastructure serves as the material base for the activities of BASIS INTERNATIONAL . 3.2 ORGANISATIONAL STRUCTURE AND FINANCING BASIS Projects is a private family trust, which also comprises of two commercially, financially and legally separate enterprises, namely BASIS INTERNATIONAL and BASIS Handproducts. Both are income producing and pay income taxes. The profits are not for the benefit of the Moozhiyil family but rather flow back into the activities of the trust. The enterprises are registered with the government of Kerala. Registration is not legally required for the trust and no taxes are levied on the sale of raw agricultural products. BASIS Projects currently has a staff of 25 full-time workers and five seasonal workers (predominantly low-caste Hindus). The staff rotates among the various areas in accordance with the work demand and suitability. Wages are paid from the proceeds in those areas that are prospering at the time, depending on the situation. These temporary shifts are documented in the bookkeeping records. The tourist staff includes one travel guide, a driver, a cook, a cleaning woman, and two "allrounders". Leelamony and her daughter Theresa Moozhiyil likewise assist with the daily trips. BASIS INTERNATIONAL has six double rooms, a kitchen wing and a dining / lounge area for its use. A house is being constructed which can accommodate a large family. Also under construction is the Ayurvedic clinic with accommodations for eight persons for long-term physical and psychological treatment. Upon request visitors can be referred to lodging accommodations with four farming families of the district ("homestead tourism"). Two offices, computers and a small bus with 15 seats complete the material infrastructure of the project. The overall project has a financial volume of 30,000 - 50,000 Euro per year. About a third of the total comes from sales of BASIS Handproducts, from BASIS INTERNATIONAL and donations of the Gießen-based help organization "Förderkreis Indienhilfe e.V", which guarantees a minimum donation of nearly 10,000 Euro per year. 3.3 OBJECTIVES AND MAIN ACTIVITIES The objective of the village development project was formulated by the Moozhiyil family on the basis of the problem analysis of their location as follows: "The goal is to give the male and female inhabitants of the village the possibility to develop their independence and improve their living situation through their own initiative." With a view to realising these goals the project has developed a variety of activities. This includes training and continuing education for interested inhabitants on subjects such as:
Thus far, approximately 1,000 persons have been trained in the various occupations. For a monthly charge of 50 Rupees participating (and non-participating) parents can take their small children to the project's kindergarten, where the children can learn through games and not through rote and force. Each year in April and May a four-week holiday programme is provided for up to 100 school children from the area with a view to reducing social isolation and offering alternatives to the rigid school system. Drinking water facilities and toilets were build together with the village residents, who also donated of their own time and money to the project. Emergency aid (partially in the form of loans) and support for home construction (also through getting cheap bank loans) for persons abandoned by their families (e.g. due to love marriage), for single parents and disabled persons, as well as basic medical care and counselling (by Mrs. Moozhiyil) complement the activities spectrum. The aim of BASIS INTERNATIONAL is
The extensive village development project is an exemplary vehicle - a micro- and macro-cosmos of Kerala, India, as well as a paragon of a learning model. To promote international exchanges and self-development, from 1990 - 1997, thirteen six-week international work camps were held in the framework of the project. The camps were attended by 130 young adults between the ages of 18 and 26, who helped out in the various village development areas according to their abilities and interests. The programme, which was funded by the German Ministry for Family, Senior Citizens, Women and Youth, was discontinued in 1997 due to lack of funding. For the advancement of international exchanges and in order to get the necessary action research based support on professional issues, BASIS has regularly applied for ASA scholarships (work-study stays) with the Carl Duisberg Gesellschaft (CDG) since 1996. Thus far, 14 students have already completed their programmes and three students are still in the process. The Ayurvedic clinic is approaching completion. It will offer guests the opportunity to experience holistic Asian healing methods and to engage in intensive intercultural encounters. The actual tourism programme has been operating with the support of the Waschbär-Reisen travel agency, Ballrechten, Germany since 1997. Up to four times a year 10-12 persons visit the project for three weeks. The regular programme includes a one-week round trip through Kerala and Tamil Nadu, daily outings, boat trips in the backwaters region, elephant rides, integration in the project work and many discussions with the project staff. The programme can be structured flexibly, e.g. through stays with local families (up to now: spice growers, tea farmers, general farmers, fishers, and the spectrum is growing). Changes are made without negatively affecting the nature and purpose of the visit. The "India for Family" programme has been offered since Autumn 2001. Up to twice a year (Autumn and Christmas holidays) 6-12 persons are taken in for the purpose of learning about Indian village life, schools, markets, festivals, and the flora and fauna. In addition, children oriented programmes are offered. 4. ASSESSMENT The evaluation of BASIS INTERNATIONAL against the TODO! criteria for socially responsible tourism resulted in the following assessment: Contest Criterion: BASIS INTERNATIONAL is integrated in the continually growing village development project, which even performs government functions, since the government either does not or qualitatively inadequately performs its assigned responsibilities (examples: drinking water supply, medical supplies, kindergarten). The project is a self-help undertaking: with the exception of cases of extreme need nothing is provided free-of-charge in any of the sectors.
Participation is enhanced through mutual acceptance, as illustrated by the fact that
Contest Criterion:
Contest Criterion: Economic:
Social:
Cultural:
Contest Criterion:
Contest Criterion:
Contest Criterion:
Contest Criterion:
Contest Criterion:
Contest Criterion:
5. RECOMMENDATIONS The overall project has meanwhile reached a size and complexity, which urgently require not only reliance on the memory of the Moozhiyil family and their staff, but also the introduction of a monitoring and evaluation system (perhaps with the help of a competent ASA scholarship recipient) for systematic observation of the performance of project components, evaluation of their impact, and documentation of both. Otherwise, there is a danger of excessive focusing on certain knowledge carriers, dissipation of energy and oversights, particularly of unplanned effects of measures - all this would be detrimental to a continually participatory planning system. The almost unmanageable size of the overall project, which is to be additionally expanded through further planned measures, renders it advisable to make increasing use of the services of local government and non-government institutions, and to promote and strengthen them. Thus, the project could be transferred as a functional, spatial, economic and time-limited bundle of measures into a programme in co-operation with local partners, which would also contribute to its sustainability. A sensible increase in tourist numbers is to be desired in order to gradually get away from the support of the Förderkreis association. The view of Anisha Schubert (1999, p. 19) meets with full agreement from us: "Whilst the co-operation with Förderkeis Indienhilfe e.V. is indeed positive and built on a friendly foundation, there is still dependency, lack of equilibrium, the compulsion to account for expenses, formal requests, etc. to get the support. The step toward independence through tourism and production, or, in other words, toward financing through active performance, has led to greater desire to take on responsibility and increased work performance among male and female staff than in the case of financing through donations." The staff should be provided with written employment contracts. That would prevent any feelings of uncertainty and dependency. Presentation of a written document with contractually formulated description of the job duties and regulations of the employment relationship is useful in case of changing over to a new employer. The programme could be enriched by the addition of hiking routes, particularly in the Western Ghats. Trekking is work-intensive and yields a relatively high income spread. Moreover, it promotes a meditative encounter with oneself and the environment. The encounter between the cultures as one of the main aims of the project should not be limited to German holiday travellers alone. If possible, the project should be provided with the necessary support for identification of appropriate partners from the external tourism industry outside Germany. 6. CONCLUSION The initiators and actors of the BASIS Project have succeeded in formulating the goals for an integrated village development project based on a holistic problem analysis and to implement it in stages. The embedding of BASIS INTERNATIONAL into the village development project is to the benefit of both the project and the tourists: the village residents benefit from the positive economic, social and cultural impact of tourism and tourists can gain diverse and profound insights into the living circumstances of the local people. The goals and concept of the BASIS Projects are to be commended to the fullest. To aid in the implementation, certain instruments should be introduced or improved: the development of an participatory monitoring and evaluation system, increased involvement by government and non-government institutions/organisations and the expansion of BASIS INTERNATIONAL and BASIS Handproducts. with a view to freeing the project from its dependence on donated funds.
In co-operation
with: |